Let me begin by saying how adorable this is and that this critique only reflects how I feel about the coloring that you did on the work. As i'm not critiquing at the moment for his sketch. I love the atmosphere you created for this piece, it's very fitting, (Is it odd for me to say that I feel that way right now working on the computer with only the glow of the screen to keep company?) Anyways, the warmer colors are very complimentary for the picture, the interior wood is also played with the same warm colors with gives a cozy feeling to the rest of the pic. Shadowing is great (with exception to one or two items I will list later, and it's me just being excessive on watch) Originality however, suffers in this pic, and gains its points from your color palette choice and work post creation as a sketch. (as well as your mane fixing) However, the only real critique I have for this is really two things. First off, (I love the shadowing) the shadowing however, does not seem to fully cover certain areas and I feel like i'm missing part of the portrait because of the single source of light. I feel that some offsetting would be appropriate (lightening the whole of) so that the picture wouldn't feel so confined. It also leads the viewers eye off track from the main part of the portrait (The eye is lazy and therefore attracted to white or lighter spaces) And it also draws attention from spike. Who is a good part of the pic. He also feels a little left off because of this. The light also seems to lightly shrink in only one direction, but i'm willing to overlook it because it would take away from the picture because major parts would be lighted while others were not. With all that said though I will say this. I would argue that this is a difficult picture to color and light, you have only one visible light source and few shadows from the original. For what you had, I would say you did masterful, and if I were in your position, I would not be able to do as good a job with this pic as you have done. Great work.
It's long been a theory of mine that every character in the ponyverse is 'attuned' to one of the Elements of Harmony. From episode 1 it's been obvious that Spike's Element is Loyalty.
I feel that some offsetting would be appropriate (lightening the whole of) so that the picture wouldn't feel so confined. It also leads the viewers eye off track from the main part of the portrait (The eye is lazy and therefore attracted to white or lighter spaces) And it also draws attention from spike. Who is a good part of the pic. He also feels a little left off because of this. The light also seems to lightly shrink in only one direction, but i'm willing to overlook it because it would take away from the picture because major parts would be lighted while others were not.
With all that said though I will say this. I would argue that this is a difficult picture to color and light, you have only one visible light source and few shadows from the original. For what you had, I would say you did masterful, and if I were in your position, I would not be able to do as good a job with this pic as you have done. Great work.
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.